Friday, February 7, 2020

Birds of Prey finds catharsis in its brutality

Margot Robbie in Birds of Prey. Image courtesy Warner Bros.
Somewhere between the innumerable mangled limbs and supersized bursts of energy that coat the surface Birds of Prey: And the Fantabulous Emancipation of One Harley Quinn is unbridled rage against an oppressive society. While the film doesn't have the depth to tackle the depths of the cause for its rage, it has plenty of grit and tenacity that nearly make up for it. This is a film dedicated to vengeance and the unlikely friendships that arise from that pursuit.

Birds of Prey picks up sometime after the conclusion of Suicide Squad. Harley Quinn (Margot Robbie) is single after breaking things off with the Joker and struggling to cope with life without per pudding. Despite her best efforts to start over, she soon finds herself in the sights of aspiring crime lord and professional chauvinist Roman Sionis (an enthusiastic Ewan McGregor) and his psychotic underling Victor Zsasz (Chris Messina). Roman threatens to kill Harley unless she can find a diamond in the possession of young pickpocket Cassandra Cain (Ella Jay Basco). Also on the case are Detective Renee Montoya (Rosie Perez), who is working with lounge singer Black Canary (Jurnee Smollett-Bell), and the mysterious Huntress (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) who is out for revenge. Roman soon double crosses Harley, and it's up to her, Renee, Black Canary, and Huntress to protect Cassandra and stop Roman from becoming the most powerful villain in Gotham.

Birds of Prey is the most brutal of the D.C. films. Every fight scene functions as an excuse to break somebody's legs or take a wild swing at a skull with an aluminum baseball bat to inflict as much pain as possible. The film gets pretty hardcore, culminating in an absolutely vicious final kill that leaves folks cringing from the delirious excess of the endeavor. Birds of Prey combines the grounded violence of the Batman flicks with the Looney Tunes shorts it references to create this bizarre concoction of cartoonish human pain. The surreal violence fits the reality of Harley, who serves as the protagonist and the film's narrator. Harley's world is vicious and silly, heightened even more by the heartbreak from ending a long-term relationship. This is a breakup movie at its core, so it makes sense for Harley Quinn to shuffle through anger and grief to find some value in her self after shedding the last vestiges of her relationship. It takes a while, but in the case of any breakup Harley realizes she's better off alone than with a man who treats her poorly.

Even taking account Harley's role as a twisted narrator, Birds of Prey makes a few unnecessarily uncomfortable narrative choices. One scene, in which Harley is nearly date raped (Black Canary reluctantly comes to the rescue), is a bothersome trope that is ultimately unnecessary to serve either of its purposes. Removing Harley's filter for a moment, the scene exists as a character development arc for Black Canary to showcase her battle against her conscience and her adeptness as a brawler. Both are either referenced or made evident frequently before and after and could be introduced independent of an attempted rape. Adding Harley's filter back though reflects the film's underlying complication with its critique of societal misogyny. Birds of Prey is not subtle with its depictions of gross men doing gross things, but the film misses out on exploration of the nuances that allow these things to happen. There is a lot of potential for Harley to wail on a dude cutting in front of her in line or interrupting her in the midst of a speech, which would be as cathartic as beating up a pair of attempted racists. Birds of Prey had a lot of options it could take to emphasize its points about misogyny, so resorting to rape attempts to prove the point is cliché and dents some of the film's thematic resonance.

But there remains satisfaction with aggressors, especially as the film's female stars come together to fight against an army of male oppressors. The final fight has a few nice little moments to show the characters bonding amid the cascade of bullets and broken bones that add a feminine touch to the carnage. The sequence and the final cool down before the credits roll merges the raging sexism and Harley's personal journey to a logical conclusion. In a world in which men are obnoxiously dominant and perpetually dangerous, it makes sense for women to band together to help and protect one another. Birds of Prey isn't a paragon of feminism, but it at least allows viewers to blow off a little steam by living vicariously through its female heroes and anti-heroes.

Review: Three out of Five Stars

Click here to see the trailer.

Rating: R
Run time: 109 minutes
Genre: Action

tl;dr

What Worked: Margot Robbie, Ewan McGregor, Huntress

What Fell Short: Tropes

What To Watch Instead: Mad Love

No comments:

Post a Comment